James P. Scanlan, Attorney at Law

Home Page

Curriculum Vitae

Publications

Published Articles

Conference Presentations

Working Papers

page1

Journal Comments

Truth in Justice Articles

Measurement Letters

Measuring Health Disp

Outline and Guide to MHD

Summary to MHD

Solutions

page3

Solutions Database

Irreducible Minimums

Pay for Performance

Between Group Variance

Concentration Index

Gini Coefficient

Reporting Heterogeneity

Cohort Considerations

Relative v Absolute Diff

Whitehall Studies

AHRQ's Vanderbilt Report

NHDR Measurement

NHDR Technical Issues

MHD A Articles

MHD B Conf Presentations

MHD D Journal Comments

Consensus/Non-Consensus

Spurious Contradictions

Institutional Corresp

page2

Scanlan's Rule

Outline and Guide to SR

Summary to SR

Bibliography

Semantic Issues

Employment Tests

Case Study

Case Study Answers

Case Study II

Subgroup Effects

Subgroup Effects NC

Illogical Premises

Illogical Premises II

Inevitable Interaction

Interactions by Age

Literacy Illustration

RERI

Feminization of Poverty S

Explanatory Theories

Mortality and Survival

Truncation Issues

Collected Illustrations

Income Illustrations

Framingham Illustrations

Life Table Illustrations

NHANES Illustrations

Mort/Surv Illustration

Credit Score Illustration

Intermediate Outcomes

Representational Disp

Statistical Signif SR

Comparing Averages

Meta-Analysis

Case Control Studies

Criminal Record Effects

Sears Case Illustration

Numeracy Illustration

Obesity Illusration

LIHTC Approval Disparitie

Recidivism Illustration

Consensus

Algorithm Fairness

Mortality and Survival 2

Mort/Survival Update

Measures of Association

Immunization Disparities

Race Health Initiative

Educational Disparities

Disparities by Subject

CUNY ISLG Eq Indicators

Harvard CRP NCLB Study

New York Proficiency Disp

Education Trust GC Study

Education Trust HA Study

AE Casey Profic Study

McKinsey Achiev Gap Study

California RICA

Nuclear Deterrence

Employment Discrimination

Job Segregation

Measuring Hiring Discr

Disparate Impact

Four-Fifths Rule

Less Discr Alt - Proc

Less Discr Altl - Subs

Fisher v. Transco Serv

Jones v. City of Boston

Bottom Line Issue

Lending Disparities

Inc & Cred Score Example

Disparities - High Income

Underadjustment Issues

Absolute Differences - L

Lathern v. NationsBank

US v. Countrywide

US v. Wells Fargo

Partial Picture Issues

Foreclosure Disparities

File Comparison Issues

FHA/VA Steering Study

CAP TARP Study

Disparities by Sector

Holder/Perez Letter

Federal Reserve Letter

Discipline Disparities

COPAA v. DeVos

Kerri K. V. California

Truancy Illustration

Disparate Treatment

Relative Absolute Diff

Offense Type Issues

Los Angeles SWPBS

Oakland Disparities

Richmond Disparities

Nashville Disparities

California Disparities

Denver Disparities

Colorado Disparities

Nor Carolina Disparitie

Aurora Disparities

Allegheny County Disp

Evansville Disparities

Maryland Disparities

St. Paul Disparities

Seattle Disparities

Minneapolis Disparities

Oregon Disparities

Beaverton Disparities

Montgomery County Disp

Henrico County Disparitie

Florida Disparities

Connecticut Disparities

Portland Disparities

Minnesota Disparities

Massachusetts Disparities

Rhode Island Disparities

South Bend Disparities

Utah Disparities

Loudoun Cty Disparities

Kern County Disparities

Milwaukee Disparities

Urbana Disparities

Illinois Disparities

Virginia Disparities

Behavior

Suburban Disparities

Preschool Disparities

Restraint Disparities

Disabilities - PL 108-446

Keep Kids in School Act

Gender Disparities

Ferguson Arrest Disp

NEPC Colorado Study

NEPC National Study

California Prison Pop

APA Zero Tolerance Study

Flawed Inferences - Disc

Oakland Agreement

DOE Equity Report

IDEA Data Center Guide

Duncan/Ali Letter

Crim Justice Disparities

U.S. Customs Search Disp

Deescalation Training

Career Criminal Study

Implicit Bias Training

Drawing Inferences

Diversion Programs

Minneapolis PD Investig

Offense Type Issues CJD

Innumerate Decree Monitor

Massachusetts CJ Disparit

Feminization of Poverty

Affirmative Action

Affirm Action for Women

Other Affirm Action

Justice John Paul Stevens

Statistical Reasoning

The Sears Case

Sears Case Documents

The AT&T Consent Decree

Cross v. ASPI

Vignettes

Times Higher Issues

Gender Diff in DADT Term

Adjustment Issues

Percentage Points

Odds Ratios

Statistical Signif Vig

Journalists & Statistics

Multiplication Definition

Prosecutorial Misconduct

Outline and Guide

Misconduct Summary

B1 Agent Cain Testimony

B1a Bev Wilsh Diversion

B2 Bk Entry re Cain Call

B3 John Mitchell Count

B3a Obscuring Msg Slips

B3b Missing Barksdale Int

B4 Park Towers

B5 Dean 1997 Motion

B6 Demery Testimony

B7 Sankin Receipts

B7a Sankin HBS App

B8 DOJ Complicity

B9 Doc Manager Complaints

B9a Fabricated Gov Exh 25

B11a DC Bar Complaint

Letters (Misconduct)

Links Page

Misconduct Profiles

Arlin M. Adams

Jo Ann Harris

Bruce C. Swartz

Swartz Addendum 2

Swartz Addendum 3

Swartz Addendum 4

Swartz Addendum 7

Robert E. O'Neill

O'Neill Addendum 7

Paula A. Sweeney

Robert J. Meyer

Lantos Hearings

Password Protected

OIC Doc Manager Material

DC Bar Materials

Temp Confidential

DV Issues

Indexes

Document Storage

Pre 1989

1989 - present

Presentations

Prosec Misc Docs

Prosec Misc Docs II

Profile PDFs

Misc Letters July 2008 on

Large Prosec Misc Docs

HUD Documents

Transcripts

Miscellaneous Documents

Unpublished Papers

Letters re MHD

Tables

MHD Comments

Figures

ASPI Documents

Web Page PDFs

Sears Documents

Pages Transfer


Publications 1989 - present


COPAA v. DeVos
"Discipline disparities in Md. schools," Daily Record (June 22, 2018)
"Misunderstood Effects of Baltimore police consent decree," Daily Record (Feb. 16, 2017)
Racial Impact Statement Laws
Baltimore Decree post
Partial Picture Issue Undermins Chadbourne Pay Equity Case
"The Mismeasure of Health Disparities," J Public Health Management and Practice (July/Aug. 2016)
"Is the Disparate Impact Doctrine Unconstitutionally Vague?"
"Perverse Enforcement of Fair Lending Laws," Mortgage Banking (May 2014)
American Banker 11-10-14
"Race and Mortality Revisited," Society (July/August 2014)
American Banker 1-8-14
The Paradox of Lowering Standards (Baltimore Sun, Aug. 5, 2013)
American Banker 6-14-13
American Banker 4-24-13
American Banker 8-14-12
American Banker 6-14-12
  • "Can We Actually Measure Health Disparities?," Chance (Spring, 2006)

Can We Actually Measure Health Disparities?.pdf
"Statistical Proof of Discrimination," in Affirmative Action, An Encyclopedia (2004)
John Paul Stevens, in Affirmative Action, An Encyclopedia
Wards Cove Packing Co. v. Atonio (Aff Action Encyclopedia)
  • Entries on "Harvard Model," "John Paul Stevens," "Manifest Imbalance Standard," "Statistical Proof of Discrimination," "Wards Cove v. Atonio" in Affirmative Action: An Encyclopedia (James A. Beckman ed.), Greenwood Publishing (2004)

  • “Understanding Racial Differences in Infant Mortality,”
    PrenatalEd Update (Oct. 2000)

Understanding Racial Differences.pdf
  • “Race and Mortality,” Society (Jan/Feb 2000) (reprinted in Current (Feb. 2000))

Race and Mortality.pdf
Both Sides Misuse Data in Credit Discrimination Debate, American Banker, 7-22-98
  •  
  • "Responsive Banks Hurt By Improper Data Interpretation," The Montgomery Journal (May 5, 1998)

"Perils of Using Statistics to Show Presence or Absence of Loan Bias," American Banker, 1-3-97
"Statistical Anomaly Penalizes Fair Lending Effort," American Banker, 11-18-97

"Women Emplyee's Case Against Publix, Built on Wrong Data, Doesn't Compute," Miami Daily Business Review (Aug. 2, 1996)


  • "Mired in Numbers," Legal times (Oct. 21, 1996)

Mired in Numbers (PDF Format)
  • "When Statistics Lie," Legal Times (Jan. 1, 1996)

When Statistics Lie (Legal Times, Jan. 1, 1996)
  • "Strictly Scrutinizing Affirmative Action," Legal Times (1994-1995 Supreme Court Review) (July 31, 1995)

Strictly Scrutinizing Affirmative Action (PDF Format)
  • "No Substitute for the Real thing: Class-Based Affirmative Action Won't Achieve the Same Results," Legal Times (May 1, 1995)

No Substitute for the Real Thing (PDF Format)
  • "Recent Multimillion-Dollar Settlements May Cause Employers to Avoid Hiring Women and Minorities for Less Desireable Jobs to Improve Statistical Picture," The National Law Journal (Mar. 27, 1995) 

Recent Multimillion-Dollar Settlements (PDF Format)
Legal Times Letter on McCleskey v. Kemp (june 13, 1994)
  • "Divining Difference," Chance (Fall, 1994)

Divining Difference.pdf
  • "Measuring Hiring Discrimination," The Labor Law Journal July, 1993)

Measuring Hiring Discrimination
  • "Getting it Straight When Statistics Can Lie," Legal Times (June 28, 1993)

Getting it Straight When Statistics Can Lie (PDF format)
  • "Unlucky Stores: Are They All Guilty of Discrimination?" San Francisco Daily Journal (Jan. 29, 1993)

Unlucky Stores (PDF Format)
  • "Study Misses Mark on Discrimination in D.C." Washington Business Journal (May 25, 1992)

"Bias Data Can Make the Good Look Bad," American Banker 4-27-92
  • "The Curious Case of Affirmative Action for Women," Society (Jan.-Feb., 1992) (reprinted in Current (June 1992))

The Curious Case of Affirmative Action for Women.pdf
  • "Low Entrance Standards Hardest on Minorities," NCAA News (Dec. 18, 1991)

  • "Slip-Up in the Civil Rights Bill," Legal Times (Dec. 11, 1991)

Slip up in the Civil Rights Bill (PDF Format)
  • "Setbacks Ahead for Set-Asides," Legal Times (May 21, 1991)

Setbacks Ahead for Set-Asides (PDF Format)
  • "Can Affirmative Action Survive the Struggle?" Legal Times (Jan. 21, 1991)

Can Affirmative Action Survive the Struggle (PDF Format)
  • "The Perils of Provocative Statistics," The Public Interest (Winter, 1991) (reprinted in the Course Reader for "Quantitative Reasoning and Statistical Methods in Planning I" at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology)

The Perils of Provocative Statistics (PDF Format)
  • "Comment on McLanahan, Sorensen, and Watson's 'Sex Differences in Poverty, 1950 1980,'" Signs:  Journal of Women In Culture and Society (Winter, 1991)

 


Comment on McLanahan et al.'s "Sex Differences in Poverty, 1950-1980"
  • "Double-Edged Civil Rights," The National Law Journal (Nov. 5, 1990)

Double-Edged Civil Rights (PDF Format)
  • "Race, Color Bias Inseparable," Fulton County Daily Report (June 26, 1990)

  • "The Court's Little Surprise," Legal Times (1989-1990 Supreme Court Review) (July 23, 1990)

The Court's Little Surprise
  •  "An Issue of Numbers," The National Law Journal (Mar. 5, 1990)

 


An Issue of Numbers (Mar. 5, 1990)
  • "Patterson v. McLean and Affirmative Action," The Labor Law Journal (Mar. 1990)

Patterson v. McLean
  • "Numbers Can Mislead on Race and Death," Legal Times (July 9, 1990) (reprinted as part of the proceedings of the Criminal Section of the American Bar Association annual meeting in August, 1990)

Numbers Can Mislead on Race and Death
  • "Broadcasting Cases to Transmit Message on Racial Preferences," Legal Times (Mar. 19,1990)

Broadcasting Cases to Transmit (PDF Format)
  • "Strategic Defense Can Be Dangerous," The New Leader (June 12-26, 1989)

  • Strategic Defense Can Be Dangerous.pdf

     

    • "Indiscriminate Reading of Statistics Can 'Prove' Bias Where None Exists," "Manhattan Lawyer (Apr. 24, 1989)

    • "Time Running Out on Minority Preferences," Legal Times (Dec. 11, 1989)

    Time Running Out on Minority Preferences (PDF Format)
    • "Are Bias Statistics Nonsense?" Legal Times (Apr. 17, 1989)

    Are Bias Statistics Nonsense? (PDF Format)
    • "Striking Down Set-Aside System, Court Tackles Complex Issue, " The National Law Journal (Mar. 6, 1989)

    Striking Down Set-Aside System (PDF Format)
    • "Affirmative Action for Women:  New Twist on an Old Debate," Legal Times (Dec. 5, 1988) (reprinted in The Corporate Board (July-August, 1989))

    Affirmative Action for Women (PDF Format)